Monday, June 22, 2009

This Old State or How to Fix California, Step One...

With the state on the verge of fiscal meltdown and our esteemed state representatives too busy pointing fingers at each other and passing the buck to voters to do anything about it, I offer maneuvers that can go a long way to repairing the nation’s Golden State and restore it to its former sheen:

Scrub the State Constitution

Article I of the state’s constitution contains the following statements:

All people are by nature free and independent and have
inalienable rights. Among these are enjoying and defending life and
liberty, acquiring, possessing, and protecting property, and pursuing
and obtaining safety, happiness, and privacy.

And, of course:

Only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or
recognized in California.

Regular readers of this blog already know my stance on marriage equality. Regardless of that stance, the above declarations are examples of contradictions that we the voters are directly responsible for inserting into the state constitution. The solution in this particular case is to remove the marriage clause. Of the two, I would rather my right to liberty and privacy be codified than my requirement to marry a chick instead of a dude.

Our ability to contravene each others’ rights is described in Article II by the initiative process and Article XVIII by the amendment process. I won’t advocate throwing the baby out with the bath water here. The initiative process itself is useful. It gives the people direct access to their government by allowing them to supersede their representation. In the case of corrupted representation, the people’s ability to directly enact laws can be a good thing.

That ability can also be a bad thing. In good faith, a representative can support or oppose legislation on the Assembly floor. By the rules in the state constitution, a minority of voters can put initiatives on the ballot and effectively silence her out of doing her job, or even out of office. Assembly persons represent about 400,000 people. In any given district, conceivably, the rep. can become enmeshed in a power grab that has her more focused on keeping her post and not the business of the state. Her job, to represent the will of the people (not a well organized group of them), is thus compromised.

Another flaw in the initiative process is its relative ease. To amend the constitution by any means requires a ballot measure. How that measure is generated is disparate between the regular legislative process and the voter initiative process. For the legislature to propose an amendment requires a two-thirds majority in both the Assembly and Senate, meaning extensive debate and revision. The voter initiative process, by rule, requires signatures of 8% of the voters in the last gubernatorial election. With enough support, any jack-a-nape (or pastor) can write California law. In 2008, when Prop. 8 was submitted and passed, 694,354 signatures were required, compared to an estimated population of 36,553,215 the previous year. The 8% requirement is one of the lowest of any states and the disparity between signatories and the general population, those who propose the law and those who will live under it, is apparent.

The initiative process needs to be revised. It should be stricter and in the case of constitution amendments more difficult to achieve. Its most substantial modifications to the state constitution, defining marriage and taxation (which we will next visit) need to be thrown out or completely revamped.

In research for this series I have discovered a group that is proposing a constitutional convention to occur as early as next year. One of their top priorities is to reform the initiative and referendum process. I will not go into a great deal about Repair California, as I have yet to fully study who they are and what they want. I neither endorse nor denounce their agenda as yet. I am, however, encouraged that there is someone out there worried about more than just balancing a budget. A balanced budget has become the will o' the wisp of California politics and caused our distracted leaders to propose ridiculous cuts to vital services without seeking new revenue sources to pay for them. On behalf of Repair California, I will say that among their other concerns are: the structure of governance, the legislative and executive branches; campaign finance; term limits; changes to the two-thirds requirement for passing a budget and revenue distribution, particularly between localities and the state. See the website and decide for yourself if you’re on board.

My original goal was to post a bulleted “To Do” list of how to fix California (five easy steps!), but each one is much bigger than I’d anticipated. Therefore, for the second time this month, I will post a series. Next up will be: Taxes, Spending and the Folk Tale of a Balanced Budget.

Thursday, June 18, 2009

The Error of Progressive Pushback

Progressives are becoming increasingly polemic in their criticisms of the the Obama administration on the issue of gay rights. While I support their overall goals, those of full inclusion of the LGBT community in marriage, federal benefits, military service, definition in hate crimes legislation et al, I am also critical of their methods and focus. The diatribes against the president are misguided. The fault is being placed at the wrong feet for any actual, permanent solution to these issues of civil rights.

I should refrain from the third person when referring to progressives, as I count myself as one. The progressive agenda is to move the laws of this country forward towards inclusion, rather than preserve some ideological, and ultimately arbitrary, norm. This is why I embraced the change promised by the Obama campaign. Change that included social reforms, like health care and gay rights, and a return to the moral authority of the United States by adhering to the rule of law. The rule of law is by no means arbitrary. It is what gives us standing among the governments of the world. It is not so much an ideal to achieve, but a foundation on which to build. It is on the rule of law that we progressives, in our critique of the president, have been a bit wishy-washy and to which we must realign ourselves.

The concept of checks and balances gives the Executive branch the task of preserving the Constitution and faithfully executing the laws of the United States, among others. In some cases, especially civil rights cases, those two duties come into conflict. The Constitution affords the protections sought by the LGBT community, which the president must abide. It is also a sad fact that the laws of the United States (i.e. DoMA, DADT) have been written to deny these protections to the LGBT community, which the president must abide. The sorting of this conflict is highly politicized: by the right to appeal to its base of religious/social conservatives and by the left to appeal to its base of liberals and civil libertarians. We progressives have focused too much on this divide and we've begun to make similar, outrageous accusations which we accuse the right of making.

We were very critical of the previous administration's use of executive orders. George Bush was out of control when it came to executive orders. He expanded government by executive order, creating the Office of Homeland Security and others. He declared war by executive order, declaring air space above Afghanistan a combat zone and confiscating/vesting certain Iraqi property. He attempted legislation by executive order, convening the President’s Council on Bioethics. Executive order is a prerogative of the president, but George Bush used these orders to circumvent checks and balances, enacting policy with minimal (if any) input of the legislature.

I would like to dispel a few rumors. Firstly, memos issued by the the Department of Justice (DOJ) are not representative of the president's actions or intentions. The DOJ is not the White House, is not the voice of the White House, nor does it execute the will of the president or his advisors. We have had that problem in the past when the DOJ was instructed, allegedly, to come up with justifications for the use of torture. This is beyond the scope of the DOJ authority, being bent to the will of the president or vice president.
Their opinions were written to circumvent the rule of law. The DOJ represents the United States in criminal and civil litigation before the Supreme Court. Last week’s memo was the DOJ performing its role within the executive branch of government: to uphold the laws of the United States. The DOJ is not, anymore, in the business of constructing legal cases per terms of the White House. It is independent of the White House and doing its job. The memo lays out procedural opposition but not a compelling argument. There are premises that the Supreme Court can reject outright or that the petitioners can challenge.

Second, the DOJ memo does not liken gay marriage to incest. Here is where we begin to come off the rails, sounding like Rush Limbaugh or Bill O’Reilly. We cannot make our case by misrepresenting the arguments of our opponents. The memo cites specific case law wherein the “full faith and credit” clause of the Constitution cannot be used to force states to contravene their own policies. It uses marriage cases, appropriately, as well as workers compensation. The media, and I detest having to say this, has blown out of proportion correct citations in the memo that show how marriage law in Italy doesn’t apply in Connecticut. Arizona does not have to accept the marriage of first cousins, legal in New Mexico. California businesses do not have to conform to Massachusetts’ compensation laws. While the marriage cases cited are repugnant, they are not cited as equivalent or in the same category as same-sex marriage. The point is argued that “full faith and credit” does not force one state’s policy on another. For my money, this is one of the memo's weaker arguments because it can be wrongly interpreted as equating unchosen lifestyles with learned behavior.

The courts and the DOJ, not the White House, have rejected all petitions of the LGBT community thus far. The Obama White House has made small concessions. For instance, the military must now demonstrate how a member’s sexual orientation is a detriment to his regiment before dismissal and most recently giving some conciliatory benefits to gay and lesbian federal employees. We have criticized him for those concessions as "pandering to a Democratic voting bloc." We are loudly frightened that in the not-quite five months he has been president he has not delivered on a campaign promise. He has promised to repeal DoMA. Unfortunately, that is not his job. As president, he can only enforce the laws of the country. The DOJ can only argue in defense of the laws of the country. If the DOJ were to selectively argue cases or ignore cases based on their social relevance, we would have Bush all over again, if not worse. The justice system would be at the mercy of the social-issue-of-the-day, which could potentially include conservative assistant attorneys general writing memos on abortion. The president has stated, multiple times, that the onus of this issue is on Congress. He is correct.

We do ourselves no good in being angry at Obama and shouting that he’s abandoned the LGBT community. Is it worthwhile to petition the president or withdraw money from Democratic fundraisers? Sure. It will definitely get his attention. He absolutely needs to press Congress more in stepping up to this issue. But so do we. DoMA is a federal law. DADT is a federal law. Only Congress has the authority to change duly enacted federal laws. When the chickens ran the henhouse in the nineties, Clinton compromised on the sweeping social reforms he had proposed. His compromise came in the form of his signature on these socially unjust laws. Obama does not want to make the same mistakes as Clinton or Bush. He does not want to over extend his executive authority, temporarily fixing this or that situation, but impotent to address the overarching problem. Nor does he want to compromise due legislative process. In the scenario where Congress puts forth a bill ending marriage discrimination, service discrimination, and Obama promises to veto said bill(s), then is the time to descend on him with great vengeance and furious anger.

Right now we sound silly. We reduce legal rhetoric into inflammatory sound bites. We plow forward with legal challenges and expect the DOJ to stand aside. We demand the president over step his authority in handing us what we want. We are, in short, disorganized. The court filings are happening too soon, and the grounds on which they are being argued are shaky. We are fighting for piecemeal concessions when the issue extends far beyond marriage and military service.

There is a movement to demonstrate in front of the White House in October. In another time (as in "with an actual income") I probably would have bought a bullhorn and a plane ticket by now. We are right to bring this issue to the front door of the president. But to expect this change to come from his office alone is misguided and wrong.

Thursday, June 11, 2009

Support Our Troops... All of Them

It is a sad commentary on the state of our military that when in times of great conflict, and need, the focus of some of its most senseless abuses is its own membership. Such was the case over fifty years ago in the form of Lt. Milo Radulovich, an Air Force reservist. Such is the case today in the form of Lt. Dan Choi, an Army reservist and Arab linguist.

Milo Radulovich was the son of a Serbian immigrant born October 28, 1926. He joined the Army Air Corps in 1944 to become a meteorologist. By 1952 Radulovich had become a weather officer in the Air Force, in Dexter Michigan. Since moving to America, John Radulovich, Milo’s father, subscribed to newspapers from his homeland reportedly to keep up with events there. One of those newspapers was associated with a periodical called the American Slav Congress which had been labeled Communist by the American government. In 1952 Lt. Radulovich was discharged from the Air Force for consorting with known communist sympathizers. In other words, the lieutenant’s continued relationship with his father made him a security risk, as a weather man, to the U.S. homeland. Lt. Radulovich was granted a hearing where Air Force attorneys produced a manila envelope purportedly containing damaging evidence against him. Neither Radulovich, nor his lawyers, nor anyone present or deciding the outcome of the hearing ever saw the contents of that envelope.

In October 1953 Radulovich’s lawyers successfully put his story on the front page of the Detroit News. This caught the attention of Edward R. Murrow, who that week ran it as a feature on his weekly CBS show See It Now. In November 1953 the U.S. Secretary of the Air Force, reversed the decision declaring Radulovich a security risk. He was cleared of all charges and reinstated. For Radulovich, justice prevailed only after a bitter, uneven battle by the military. It used questionable tactics, if not outright lies during that battle against a man who only swore allegiance to his flag and was willing to put his life on the line for the country he loved. Lt. Radulovich’s own allegiance was never questioned.

On March 19, 2009 a National Guard lieutenant went on national television to say the following:



I am an infantry platoon leader in the New York Army National Guard, and by saying three words to you today—I am gay—those three words are a violation of Title 10 of the U.S. Code.
Like over twelve thousand of his fellow soldiers since 1993, Dan Choi was discharged from his service because he:
... admitted publicly that [he is] a homosexual, which constitutes homosexual conduct. [His] actions negatively affected the good order and discipline of the Army National Guard.
The greatest comfort we can give to our enemies is to fight ourselves in times of turmoil. In each of these situations the military deferred to the law to make its case against its own members. While the methods of application are deplorable, the manila envelope for Lt. Radulovich and coming out as “homosexual behavior” for Lt. Choi, the application of the law cannot be disputed. Air Force regulation 35-62 stated:
A man may be regarded as a security risk if he has close and continuing associations with communists or people believed to have communist sympathies.
U.S. Code 10 Section 654b (2) states:
A member of the armed forces shall be separated from the armed forces under regulations prescribed by the Secretary of Defense if one or more of the following findings is made... That the member has stated that he or she is a homosexual or bisexual, or words to that effect
Only the hysteria of the era could have found that a man whose father subscribed to foreign newspapers, and had no question to his own loyalty, could be a security risk. Only puritanical hysteria could find that a man is unfit for duty not by the fact of his homosexuality, but by the knowledge of it. Twelve thousand plus have lost the privilege* to fight for their country based solely on that knowledge. From bumpers stickers to keychains, lawn signs to the pages of Facebook we see the slogan everywhere, “Support Our Troops.” Only in the back of our minds do we qualify, "... but only the straight ones."

Within a month of Ed Murrow’s piece the military took action to reverse the wrongs it did to Lt. Radulovich. In the darkest moments of the Cold War a cabal of brazen journalists, of which Mr. Murrow admitted he was a late entrant, stepped up to a junior senator and said, “Enough!” Thus far the military, the Supreme Court and the president who promised to end DADT have failed to support Lt. Choi. H.R. 1283 amends Title 10 of U.S. Code, repealing DADT and replacing with a policy of nondiscrimination based on sexual orientation. It is now in committee for review. Two-thirds of the government have turned a blind eye to Lt. Choi and others. I’m not here to debate whether their reasons were just, but to get the other third to do the right thing.

*
U.S.C. 10 also declares that military service is not a Constitutional right